CanFlow Global
CBSA Criminal Enforcement at the Border: What It Means for Commercial Reporting Requirements
← All insights
cbsa-enforcementborder-complianceaci-reportingcarrier-liabilityemanifest

CBSA Criminal Enforcement at the Border: What It Means for Commercial Reporting Requirements

A recent criminal sentencing out of Manitoba highlights CBSA's enforcement reach under IRPA. For commercial importers and carriers, the parallel is clear: reporting requirements at the Canadian border are not suggestions, and the consequences of non-compliance run from administrative penalties to criminal prosecution.

CBSA’s Dual Mandate: Immigration and Customs

CBSA announced this week that a criminal investigation at the Sprague, Manitoba port of entry led to a one-year prison sentence under section 131 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) for aiding or abetting failure to report. The case involved an illegal crossing attempt. The individual pleaded guilty in Winnipeg Provincial Court and has about three months left to serve after pre-sentencing custody credit.

That’s an immigration enforcement case, not a customs one. But the underlying principle is the same one commercial importers and carriers deal with every day: if you cross the Canadian border or bring goods or people across, you report. You report accurately, completely, and on time. CBSA’s authority to investigate and prosecute non-compliance applies whether you’re attempting an illegal entry or you’re a carrier that failed to transmit a cargo manifest.

What Section 131 IRPA Means for Commercial Carriers

Section 131 IRPA makes it an offence to fail to report at a port of entry when legally required to do so. For commercial carriers, the reporting requirement isn’t section 131 directly. It’s the Reporting of Imported Goods Regulations and the related ACI (Advance Commercial Information) and eManifest rules. But the enforcement ladder is similar: administrative penalties under AMPS (Administrative Monetary Penalty System) for routine violations, and criminal prosecution under the Customs Act or IRPA for deliberate smuggling, false declarations, or organized non-compliance.

We see the administrative side weekly. A carrier files an eManifest late, or the cargo control document has a wrong consignee name, or the PARS barcode doesn’t match the shipment descriptor. CBSA issues an AMPS penalty. The Master Penalty Document sets the base amounts: CAD 250 for a late or incorrect eManifest on a highway conveyance, scaling up for repeat violations or marine/rail movements. Pay it, fix the process, move on.

The criminal side is rare in the commercial context, but it exists. If CBSA’s intelligence unit believes a carrier or importer is systematically under-reporting shipment values to evade duty, or mis-declaring controlled goods to avoid CFIA holds, or using false FIRMS codes to dodge SIMA duties on subject goods, that’s not an AMPS ticket. That’s a referral to the CBSA Criminal Investigations unit. Section 153 of the Customs Act makes smuggling or attempting to smuggle goods a criminal offence, punishable by fines up to the value of the goods or imprisonment up to five years, or both.

Reporting Requirements for Commercial Goods: ACI, eManifest, and Carrier Liability

Every commercial carrier bringing goods into Canada by highway, rail, marine or air must transmit advance cargo information to CBSA before arrival. For highway shipments under PARS (Pre-Arrival Review System), that means the carrier transmits the eManifest with the cargo control number and the importer’s broker transmits the PARS release request (the ACI paired customs coding). The eManifest must arrive at CBSA at least one hour before the driver reaches the border. For marine container shipments, it’s 24 hours before loading at the foreign port (the “24-hour rule”).

The carrier is legally responsible for the eManifest, even when a freight forwarder or customs broker prepares it on their behalf. If the manifest is late, incomplete, or contains errors that prevent CBSA from conducting a risk assessment, the carrier is the one who receives the AMPS penalty notice. The importer is responsible for the customs declaration (the CAD, which replaced the B3 as of CARM Release 3 on October 21, 2024), but the carrier owns the manifest.

That division of liability matters when something goes wrong. If a shipment arrives at the border and the driver has no eManifest on file, CBSA will not release the goods. The driver sits in secondary inspection while the carrier scrambles to transmit the missing data. If the goods are perishable or time-sensitive, the importer loses the value. If the manifest shows a different commodity than what’s actually in the truck, CBSA may seize the shipment pending investigation. If CBSA’s examination reveals undeclared goods or a false description, both the carrier and the importer are exposed: the carrier under the eManifest regulations, the importer under section 32.2 of the Customs Act (making a false or deceptive statement).

We handle commercial clearances where the importer has clean paperwork but the carrier’s manifest is a mess. The shipment sits at the port of entry until we sort it out. The reverse happens too: the carrier filed a perfect eManifest, but the importer’s broker submitted a PARS release with the wrong HS classification or a missing CUSMA certificate of origin. CBSA sends the shipment to intensive examination, the dwell time doubles, and the importer pays detention on the truck or the container.

When CBSA Opens a Criminal Investigation

CBSA’s Intelligence and Enforcement Branch runs risk assessments on every manifest. High-risk indicators include:

  • Repeated undervaluation of goods from the same importer or supplier
  • Misdescription of goods to avoid SIMA duties (for example, classifying laminate flooring as something other than the subject goods under a standing SIMA order)
  • Use of a Non-Resident Importer (NRI) structure where the beneficial owner is actually in Canada (a form of duty evasion)
  • False claims of CUSMA or CETA origin to claim preferential duty rates
  • Systematic late filing of eManifests or ACI, especially when paired with high-value or controlled goods

Any one of those can trigger a verification. Most verifications are administrative: CBSA sends a D11-6-7 verification letter asking for invoices, origin documents, or technical specs to confirm the declared value, origin, or classification. The importer responds, the broker manages the file, and the case closes with either no adjustment or a statement of adjustments (underpaid duty plus interest, no penalty if the error was an honest mistake).

If CBSA’s verification uncovers evidence of deliberate misrepresentation, the file moves from the trade compliance side to the criminal investigations side. At that point you’re dealing with investigators who have the same powers as police officers under the Customs Act and IRPA. They can execute search warrants, seize records, and compel testimony. The outcome is either a criminal charge (prosecuted by the Public Prosecution Service of Canada) or a formal administrative penalty under AMPS with a penalty rate far higher than the base amounts for routine errors.

The Practical Defense: Clean Data, Transparent Process

The best defense against both administrative and criminal exposure is accurate reporting at every stage. For carriers, that means validating the eManifest data before transmission. For importers, that means filing CADs with the correct value for duty (transaction value adjusted to the place of direct shipment to Canada, per section 48 of the Customs Act), the correct HS classification at the 10-digit level, and the correct origin and tariff treatment.

When we onboard a new client, we run a compliance audit on their import history. We pull the last twelve months of CAD filings (the ones their prior broker submitted), cross-check the declared values against the commercial invoices, verify the HS codes against the product specs, and look for red flags: repeated use of 9999.00.00.00 as a placeholder classification, declared values that don’t match the supplier’s price list, or CUSMA preference claims without certificates on file. If we find issues, we quantify the duty exposure and file a voluntary disclosure under CBSA’s Voluntary Disclosures Program before CBSA finds it themselves. A voluntary disclosure avoids penalties and limits interest to the four-year lookback under section 32.2 of the Customs Act.

The same logic applies to carrier manifest compliance. If your carrier has a pattern of late or incorrect eManifests, that’s a process failure worth fixing before CBSA’s risk-assessment algorithms flag the pattern. Detention and exam rates go up when CBSA sees repeated non-compliance from the same SCAC code or carrier FIRMS code. Your freight costs don’t just include the line-haul rate and the border crossing fee. They include the hidden cost of non-compliance: the dwell time, the exam fees, the AMPS penalties, and the reputational hit when your goods sit in secondary while the rest of the industry crosses in twenty minutes.

It is a common pattern for freight bound for Montreal sufferance warehouses. A shipment arrives at the port with a clean bill of lading but a missing or incorrect eManifest. The container sits at the terminal accruing per-diem charges while the carrier fixes the data and CBSA re-runs the risk assessment. The importer wanted the goods on the retail floor Thursday. They arrive the following Tuesday. The revenue window closed. That’s the cost of sloppy manifest hygiene.

Where the Line Is

Most importers and carriers will never face a criminal investigation. The CBSA cases that make the news are smuggling operations, organized fraud, or the kind of brazen non-compliance that no legitimate commercial player would attempt. But the reporting requirements that underpin those cases are the same requirements that govern every commercial crossing. You report, you report accurately, and you keep the records to prove it.

If your current process involves crossing your fingers and hoping CBSA doesn’t pull your shipment for exam, that’s not a process. Come talk to a broker.

Source: CSCB

Talk to a broker