Freight Contracts Written Before CARM Are Breaking in Peak Season
Canadian importers running long-term freight contracts negotiated before CARM Release 3 are finding that rigid delivery windows and penalty clauses don't account for monthly Statement of Account cycles, RPP bond constraints, or exam delays that push containers past terminal free time.
Key Takeaways
- Freight contracts negotiated 2022-2024 often lack flexibility for CARM's monthly Statement of Account cycle and RPP bond sizing constraints.
- Rigid delivery windows and demurrage penalties break when CBSA exams, missing CUSMA certificates, or SIMA verifications push containers past terminal free time.
- Peak-season volume spikes can exceed your RPP bond capacity, forcing transactional duty payment and delaying release just when carrier contracts penalize detention most.
- Sufferance warehouse buffer capacity decouples customs clearance timing from carrier pickup windows, keeping detention charges off the table.
Key Takeaways
- Freight contracts negotiated 2022-2024 often lack flexibility for CARM’s monthly Statement of Account cycle and RPP bond sizing constraints.
- Rigid delivery windows and demurrage penalties break when CBSA exams, missing CUSMA certificates, or SIMA verifications push containers past terminal free time.
- Peak-season volume spikes can exceed your RPP bond capacity, forcing transactional duty payment and delaying release just when carrier contracts penalize detention most.
- Sufferance warehouse buffer capacity decouples customs clearance timing from carrier pickup windows, keeping detention charges off the table.
The Contract You Signed in 2023 Didn’t Account for CARM
A lot of Canadian importers are running freight contracts negotiated between 2022 and early 2024, before CARM Release 3 went live on October 21, 2024. Those deals locked in competitive rates and predictable delivery windows, but they were built on assumptions that no longer hold. The old B3 filing system cleared goods on a transactional basis. CARM’s monthly Statement of Account moved duty and tax settlement to a completely different rhythm, and that shift quietly broke the timing and penalty structures in a lot of carrier agreements.
If your contract has tight delivery windows and steep demurrage clauses, the first CBSA exam or missing CUSMA certificate can trigger penalties you can’t control. The freight side of your supply chain is now colliding with the compliance side, and the contracts written before CARM didn’t leave room for that.
Where the Friction Shows Up
Container dwell time is the obvious flashpoint. We routinely see terminal free-time allowances of three to five calendar days at the Port of Montreal before per-diem storage starts. A routine import that clears on release prior to payment (RPP) under your bond posts to the monthly Statement of Account and you move the freight. An exam-flagged container sits until CBSA releases it, and we routinely see two to four business days depending on lab backlogs and officer availability. By the time you get the release, you’re into paid storage and your carrier’s contract is charging detention.
The old playbook assumed clearance was fast and predictable. CARM didn’t make clearance slower, but it did change cash flow visibility and the timing of duty assessment. If your carrier contract was written with 24- or 48-hour dock windows and no flexibility for exam delays, you’re paying for detention that has nothing to do with your logistics performance.
CARM’s Statement of Account Moves the Money
Pre-CARM, importers paid duty and GST on each B3 at the time of release (or within a short accounting period if you were on RMD). CARM’s monthly Statement of Account consolidated that into a single payment cycle. Your RPP bond covers the releases all month, and you settle the account when the statement posts. For importers with $2 million to $5 million in monthly duty and tax liability, we typically see RPP bond requirements in the $250,000 to $500,000 range to maintain continuous release capacity.
If your freight contract assumed you’d always have release capacity, but your RPP bond wasn’t sized for peak months, you hit a wall in Q4. November and December import volumes routinely run 20% to 40% higher than our clients’ Q2 baselines, and if your bond tops out, you’re stuck paying duties transactionally until the next Statement of Account clears. That delay pushes containers past free time, and your carrier penalties start accruing.
The financial side and the physical side used to move independently. CARM tied them together, and contracts that don’t account for that are breaking.
Peak Season Amplifies Everything
Carrier capacity tightens in Q4. Exam queues at CBSA get longer when import volumes spike. Drayage windows shrink when every importer is trying to get containers out of the same terminals in the same 72-hour window. If your freight contract has no buffer for customs delays, you’re paying penalties on delays that are structural to the peak season, not failures on your end.
We see this most often with importers who negotiated long rate locks in 2022 or 2023, when capacity was loose and carriers were competing hard for committed volume. Those contracts have delivery KPIs and penalty clauses that made sense in a soft market. In a tight market, with CARM cash flow layered on top, the penalties exceed the rate savings.
CUSMA Origin Claims Add Another Variable
If you’re claiming CUSMA preferential duty on apparel, auto parts, or steel products, you need the origin certificate in hand (or a signed statement from the supplier) when you file the CAD. If the cert arrives two days after the container, you either pay MFN duty upfront and file a correction under Customs Act section 32.2 within 90 days, or you hold the freight and wait for the document.
Holding freight to wait for a cert costs you free time. Releasing without the cert and correcting later costs you cash flow and a correction filing fee. Both outcomes push against a rigid freight contract that assumes goods move from gate to dock in 48 hours.
SIMA Duties on Subject Goods
Imports subject to SIMA (Special Import Measures Act) anti-dumping or countervailing duties get additional scrutiny. If you’re bringing in subject goods and the CBSA flags the shipment for verification of origin or Normal Value, you’re looking at a hold that can stretch a week or more while the agency works through the file. Your carrier contract doesn’t care that it’s a SIMA verification. It cares that the container sat for six days and you owe detention.
CBSA’s verification process is legitimate and necessary. But if your freight contract has no provision for compliance holds, you’re absorbing costs that have nothing to do with logistics performance.
What Breaks First
In a tight market, the carrier has options. If your contract is rigid and you’re consistently missing pickup windows because of customs delays, the carrier will enforce penalties or decline to renew. Importers who built their inbound procurement around 2022-2024 rate locks are finding that the cost of penalties and detention now exceeds the value of the locked rate.
The contracts that are holding up in 2026 have some combination of: flexible delivery windows, negotiated exceptions for CBSA exam delays, detention waivers for documented compliance holds, or monthly reconciliation clauses that true up charges against actual cause. The contracts that are breaking are the ones that assumed customs clearance was a solved problem.
Warehouse Flexibility as a Pressure Valve
One way importers are managing the mismatch is by building buffer capacity into their warehousing. If you have access to a Montreal sufferance warehouse with flexible intake windows, you can receive containers as soon as they release and move them out of terminal free-time, even if your final distribution isn’t ready. That decouples the customs timeline from the carrier timeline, and it keeps detention charges off the table.
FENGYE LOGISTICS runs sufferance warehouse programs that let importers hold goods under CBSA control until clearance is complete. If your freight contract is tight, warehouse flexibility is often the difference between staying on schedule and paying penalties.
The Playbook Going Forward
If you’re renewing carrier contracts in 2026 or 2027, build in room for customs variability. That means longer delivery windows, carve-outs for CBSA exam delays, and penalty structures that differentiate between logistics failures (late pickup) and compliance holds (exam, missing cert, SIMA verification). The rate you lock is less important than the flexibility you negotiate around it.
On the customs side, make sure your RPP bond is sized for peak months, your CUSMA certs are landing ahead of the freight, and your broker has line of sight into your monthly Statement of Account cycle in the CARM Client Portal. If any of those pieces are misaligned, your freight contract will punish you for it.
The 2022 playbook assumed capacity was abundant and customs was invisible. Neither assumption holds in 2026. If your freight contracts are hitting these issues, get in touch.
Frequently Asked Questions
When did CARM replace the B3 filing system in Canada?
CARM Release 3 went live on October 21, 2024, and the Commercial Accounting Declaration (CAD) replaced the B3 as the official customs entry document on the same date. Since then, all duty and tax assessments are managed through the monthly Statement of Account in the CARM Client Portal.
How long do I have to correct a customs declaration under CARM?
Under Customs Act section 32.2, you have 90 days from the time you have reason to believe a declaration is incorrect to file a correction. After that window, you need to go through the formal adjustment or refund process under sections 59 or 74.
What happens if my RPP bond runs out during peak season?
If your monthly duty and tax liability exceeds your RPP bond limit, CBSA will not grant release prior to payment on additional shipments until the current Statement of Account is settled or you increase your bond. You’ll have to pay duties transactionally on each entry, which delays release and can push containers past terminal free time.
Do freight contracts account for CBSA exam delays?
Most freight contracts negotiated before 2024 do not have carve-outs for customs exam holds. We routinely see CBSA exams add two to four business days to container dwell time, which can trigger demurrage and detention penalties if the carrier contract has tight delivery windows.
Can I claim CUSMA duty preference if the origin certificate arrives after the container?
You need the CUSMA origin certificate or signed statement from the supplier in hand when you file the CAD. If it arrives late, you can either pay MFN duty upfront and file a correction within 90 days, or hold the freight until the document arrives. Both options cost money or time.
What is a sufferance warehouse and how does it help with freight timing?
A sufferance warehouse is a CBSA-licensed facility where imported goods can be received and held under customs control before formal clearance. Moving containers from the terminal to a sufferance warehouse as soon as they arrive keeps them out of terminal free-time charges while your broker completes the CAD filing and handles any exam or documentation issues.
How much does detention and demurrage add to landed cost during peak season?
Demurrage and detention rates vary by terminal and carrier, but we routinely see per-diem charges of $150 to $300 per container once free time expires. A CBSA exam that adds three days can mean $450 to $900 in charges that your freight contract may not absorb if it lacks an exam-delay exception.
Source: FreightWaves
Frequently Asked Questions
When did CARM replace the B3 filing system in Canada?
CARM Release 3 went live on October 21, 2024, and the Commercial Accounting Declaration (CAD) replaced the B3 as the official customs entry document on the same date. Since then, all duty and tax assessments are managed through the monthly Statement of Account in the CARM Client Portal.
How long do I have to correct a customs declaration under CARM?
Under Customs Act section 32.2, you have 90 days from the time you have reason to believe a declaration is incorrect to file a correction. After that window, you need to go through the formal adjustment or refund process under sections 59 or 74.
What happens if my RPP bond runs out during peak season?
If your monthly duty and tax liability exceeds your RPP bond limit, CBSA will not grant release prior to payment on additional shipments until the current Statement of Account is settled or you increase your bond. You'll have to pay duties transactionally on each entry, which delays release and can push containers past terminal free time.
Do freight contracts account for CBSA exam delays?
Most freight contracts negotiated before 2024 do not have carve-outs for customs exam holds. We routinely see CBSA exams add two to four business days to container dwell time, which can trigger demurrage and detention penalties if the carrier contract has tight delivery windows.
Can I claim CUSMA duty preference if the origin certificate arrives after the container?
You need the CUSMA origin certificate or signed statement from the supplier in hand when you file the CAD. If it arrives late, you can either pay MFN duty upfront and file a correction within 90 days, or hold the freight until the document arrives. Both options cost money or time.
What is a sufferance warehouse and how does it help with freight timing?
A sufferance warehouse is a CBSA-licensed facility where imported goods can be received and held under customs control before formal clearance. Moving containers from the terminal to a sufferance warehouse as soon as they arrive keeps them out of terminal free-time charges while your broker completes the CAD filing and handles any exam or documentation issues.
How much does detention and demurrage add to landed cost during peak season?
Demurrage and detention rates vary by terminal and carrier, but we routinely see per-diem charges of $150 to $300 per container once free time expires. A CBSA exam that adds three days can mean $450 to $900 in charges that your freight contract may not absorb if it lacks an exam-delay exception.
Related insights
- Mexico nearshoring and Canadian inbound freight: what earlier peak season means for CAD filing and CBSA release timing
- Shenzhen APEC cargo restrictions and Canadian import timing
- CBSA Peak Season EDI Notice: What E-Commerce Importers Need to Tighten Up
- Canada Post ratifies contracts: what the end of strike disruption means for CBSA clearance and last-mile duty payment
- When European Port Strikes Delay Your Canadian Customs Filing