D10-17-38: CBSA Updates Marble and Granite Classification Guidance
CBSA's Tariff Policy Unit is updating D-memo D10-17-38 on marble and granite classification, with broker comments due November 25, 2026. If you import stone products, this is the window to flag classification friction before the guidance locks in for the next few years.
D-memo D10-17-38 just landed on CBSA’s update list: tariff classification of marble and granite blocks and slabs. The Tariff Policy Unit wants broker feedback by November 25, 2026, which means if you file CADs for stone importers, this is the time to flag what’s broken or unclear in the current guidance.
Most stone comes in under Chapter 68 (articles of stone) or Chapter 25 (raw mineral products), and the line between blocks, slabs, worked and unworked is where the duty spread sits. D10-17-38 sets out how CBSA reads “blocks” (rough-sawn, six-sided, no further processing) versus “slabs” (sawn to thickness, often polished on one face). The memo also covers what counts as “worked.” If the slab has a finished edge, a beveled corner, or a routed profile, it crosses into a different heading and often a different duty rate.
Why this D-memo matters
Marble and granite land under different tariff treatments depending on processing stage. Blocks of marble (HS 2515.12) typically enter duty-free under MFN. Slabs of marble, simply cut by sawing with a flat surface (HS 2515.12 or 6802 depending on further work), may also enter duty-free, but once you add edge work, polishing, or shaping, you’re into HS 6802 articles of stone, and the duty question shifts to whether the importer has a CUSMA, CETA, or CPTPP certificate of origin on file.
Granite follows a similar structure: blocks under HS 2516.11 or 2516.12, slabs under those same headings if merely sawn, and worked articles under HS 6802.23 or 6802.93 depending on specifics. The duty difference is usually zero under MFN for raw blocks and slabs, but GST still applies at 5% of value for duty plus duties, and if SIMA or other trade remedy measures ever hit stone products (rare but not impossible), classification suddenly becomes the first line of defence.
The bigger operational issue is CUSMA origin claims. A U.S. or Mexican supplier of granite countertops might claim CUSMA preference, which zeroes out the MFN rate (if any) and avoids potential AD/CVD down the road. But if CBSA reclassifies the goods on exam from HS 6802.23 (worked monumental or building stone) to a different subheading because the memo’s guidance was ambiguous, your origin certificate might not cover the reclassified heading, and the importer loses the preference. That triggers a correction, a Statement of Account adjustment in CARM, and sometimes an AMPS penalty if the original CAD filing was negligent.
What the update process looks like
CBSA’s Tariff Policy Unit doesn’t rewrite D-memos on a fixed schedule. When they do, it’s because case law changed, CBSA exam officers flagged inconsistent interpretation, or industry feedback built up over time. The request for broker comments by November 25, 2026 is the window to get your importers’ real-world scenarios into the next version of the memo.
If you file for a stone fabricator who imports rough slabs that get edge-polished in Canada, and the current memo’s language on “worked” versus “unworked” causes exam delays because the CBSA officer interprets it one way and your CAD classification was filed another way, document that case and send it to CSCB. The CSCB consolidates broker comments and submits them as a single industry response. CBSA reads that consolidated feedback, weighs it against their own exam data and legal interpretation, and publishes a revised D-memo. The revised version becomes the reference CBSA officers use at the border, and it’s the standard your HS classification needs to track.
Filing considerations while the memo is under review
D10-17-38 is still in force until CBSA publishes an update. If you’re filing CADs for marble or granite right now, classify per the current memo and keep notes on any exam or verification issues. If CBSA reclassifies on exam, ask for the officer’s written rationale and compare it to the memo’s language. If it doesn’t line up, that’s a potential appeal under CBSA’s recourse process, and it’s also feedback for the next memo revision.
For importers bringing in container loads of slabs through Montreal, the exam rate on stone is typically low unless there’s a prior compliance flag or the shipment description is vague. CBSA’s risk scoring in CARM looks at HS code, declared value, supplier history, and whether the importer has an RPP bond on file. A stone importer filing the same HS code every month with consistent unit values and clean release history will see mostly PARS releases with no exam. But if you switch from blocks (HS 2515) to worked slabs (HS 6802) mid-year and the value per unit jumps without explanation in the CAD, expect an exam request.
One timing note: if your stone shipment gets selected for exam and the goods are sitting in a Montreal sufferance warehouse, exam delays typically run two to four business days from the exam request to CBSA’s release or detention decision. The warehouse dwell fees keep running, so a misclassification that triggers an exam can cost the importer storage fees before the goods even leave the port. That’s the kind of thing a clear D-memo prevents.
The broader context: CARM and classification consistency
CARM’s Statement of Account system means CBSA can adjust your CAD up to four years after release if they find a classification error on audit. Stone products are a known audit target because the blocks-versus-slabs distinction is a common filing mistake.
If D10-17-38 gets updated with clearer guidance on what counts as “worked,” that reduces your importer’s exposure to retroactive duty assessments. If the update doesn’t clarify the grey areas, you’re filing the same ambiguous classification for another few years and hoping CBSA’s exam officers interpret it your way.
The comment deadline is November 25, 2026. If you file for stone importers and you’ve seen classification friction at the border, send your notes to CSCB. Most D-memo updates are minor clarifications, not overhauls. If you’ve had exam reclassifications or CBSA requests for additional documentation on slab imports in the past year, that’s the signal to review your HS codes now before the memo locks in for the next cycle. Get in touch if you want a second set of eyes on your stone CADs.
Source: CSCB
Related insights
- D10-14-38 Update: CBSA Tightens the Line on Unassembled Furniture Classification
- CITT contact page update: when you actually need the Tribunal's number
- D10-15-29 update: why handbag classification still trips up CAD filers
- D10-2-3 Gets Pulled — What It Means for Sugar Imports and the D-Memo Cleanup Wave
- CBSA Is Rewriting D10-15-22 on Auto Transmission Parts — Here's What Importers Should Watch